What are the best alternatives to milk in coffee? The best substitutes for milk are half-and-half and heavy cream. However, there are milk alternatives that do not have dairy. Soy, oat, and almond milk are the best choice for anyone who prefers coffee without milk.
A lot of people view coffee and milk as inseparable: cappuccinos, lattes, flat whites as well as cafe con leche are all popular coffees made with milk, which many coffee drinkers adore.
Although many prefer a black coffee without milk, there are many milk alternatives, dairy and non-dairy, which you can include in your morning coffee.
If you continue reading this article, we’ll provide our comprehensive list of the best alternatives to the milk used in coffee, including dairy and non-dairy options, and discuss their top and bottom qualities. We’ll also answer some issues you might face in deciding on the best substitute for milk in coffee.
The Top Milk Alternatives in Coffee
Here are our top choices for coffee substitutes that can be made with milk. We’ll begin with the most similar dairy alternatives and switch to dairy products derived from plants for coffee.
Half-and-Half offers the closest you can achieve to milk without using milk.
It’s a blend consisting of equal portions of whole milk and equally heavy cream. That’s why it looks so much like milk when you pour it into your cup of coffee.
The Half-and-Half recipe is a convenient and tasty option for those who need to replenish with milk for their cup of coffee if they have to go out to the kitchen or cannot find it in the stores.
To make Half-and-Half by yourself, mix equal amounts of milk and heavy cream into a jar and shake it until it is well mixed. Then, voila! Half-and-Half can for your morning coffee.
2. Heavy Cream
Following Half-and-Half, the most suitable alternative to milk is heavy cream.
Heavy cream is also derived from cows’ milk. However, there are several ways in which they differ. For one, heavy cream is thicker than milk.
Furthermore, heavy cream has a higher percentage of fat than milk. This is because it comes from butterfat found in milk. Making heavy milk cream naturally separates from milk due to its fat content.
While heavy cream is high in calories and has a more fat-rich percentage than milk, it could be an excellent substitute for your coffee because of its quality and richness.
In addition, you consume it in such small quantities in your coffee that there’s no reason to be concerned about its high-fat concentrations.
3. Oat Milk
The first non-dairy milk substitute alternative, oat milk, is the third spot due to its similar texture and taste—identical texture and flavor.
It’s an excellent choice for those concerned about health in their coffee vegans, vegetarians, and non-vegans because it is less fat-laden than milk alternatives, such as half and half.
California Farms makes barista-specific oatmeal milk specifically to be used in coffee beverages.
It is perfectly steaming, making it an ideal milk substitute for your cappuccino or latte. It also doesn’t contain stabilizers or gums. This makes it ideal for enhancing the flavor of your coffee naturally.
The well-known oat drink company Oatly also produces an espresso version of their oat milk, a favorite among consumers.
It’s creamy and thick. It’s perfect for adding to your coffee. It also has no added sugar, so you’re guaranteed to begin your day healthily.
4. Coffee Creamer
Coffee creamers are a second option to milk, which is generally dairy-free.
The majority of the time, coffee creamer is composed of oil, sugar, and thickener, so if you prefer your coffee to be sweeter, it could be an excellent choice.
Coffee creamer is available in powder, and liquid forms, which the latter is a good option if you don’t have the space to keep your creamer in a fridge.
Both the solid and liquid forms are available in a variety of flavors.
A well-known coffee cream brand, the Coffee-Mate provides many powders and liquid creamer flavors: hazelnut vanilla caramel, french vanilla, and much more!
If you’re seeking a flavor that resembles regular milk, opt for the classic taste.
Be aware that it is more processed and has more sugar than the alternatives listed above, making it not the ideal option for health-conscious people who drink coffee.
5. Bulletproof Coffee
Bulletproof Coffee is a fat-rich Keto coffee choice that is especially suitable for following this Keto Diet. It consists of freshly made coffee, grass-fed unsalted butter, and MCT (medium-chain triglyceride) coconut oil.
Although the mix may seem odd, mixing the three ingredients creates a creamy, latte-like consistency and is the ideal morning drink Keto-friendly.
The concept of Bulletproof caffeine is to stimulate your metabolism first, early in the morning. This is where MCT oil and butter come into play.
The founders of Bulletproof coffee offer their MCT-infused oil, Brain Octane, which is triple-distilled and comes from pure coconut oil.
There is also the option of purchasing premixed Bulletproof cold brew coffee in various flavors, including mocha and vanilla.
Although many ketogenic dieters swear to Bulletproof coffee, the beverage might not be the right option for everyone.
Although it’s an excellent fuel for those following the low-carb and very fat Ketogenic diet, it is packed with saturated fats. So should you not consume it when following a typical diet, you could experience negative health consequences.
6. Soy Milk
Due to its silky texture, Soy milk is an excellent alternative to milk that isn’t dairy in coffee. Naturally, it has a more sweet taste, and you might be able to eliminate the sugar in your coffee if you traditionally use soymilk instead of milk.
7. Almond Milk
Then, almond milk, another dairy-free drink, complete our milk alternatives. As with soy milk, it has an inherent sweetness, making it an excellent choice for a cup of coffee and sweet pastry.
Almond milk is an excellent alternative for vegans who suffer from lactose intolerance, particularly those who want to reduce their carbohydrate or soy consumption.
Many almond milk barista blends are available on the market to make you forget that you consumed actual milk with your cup of coffee.
Califa Farms offers two almond milk alternatives, including the barista blend almond milk creamer.
Other Questions Asked
Here are the most frequently asked questions relating to milk replacement in coffee. We hope you will find this information as valuable as the rest of the article!
What is the best substitute for milk that coffee has?
You can guess that heavy cream is the best substitute for coffee milk. Its high-fat content and thick texture contribute to its richness, making it an ideal option to add coffee if you’re seeking creaminess.
If you’re seeking a creamy dairy-free milk substitute, we suggest using soymilk and soy milk made specifically for coffee.
Soy milk is generally thicker than other milk made from non-dairy ingredients, resulting in more creaminess in coffee.
Which milk substitute tastes the most similar to milk?
If you’re looking for a substitute for coffee milk that tastes similar, it’s time to look into it half-and-half.
Since it is 50 percent milk, It will have the closest taste to milk you could obtain without using milk.
If you’re trying to remain milk-free, Oat milk offers one of the most similar tastes to milk you can enjoy while not consuming dairy.
The product is naturally sweet as soymilk and almond milk, which means it can give the appearance of a dairy-like flavor suitable for vegans and lactose-intolerant people who drink coffee.
Which is the best substitute for milk in coffee?
The best choice for a healthy milk substitute from coffee depends on your preferences.
Bulletproof coffee isn’t the best alternative when you’re looking to stay clear of the excessive amount of fat cream.
Coffee creamer is not recommended if you’re staying clear from sugar-added items.
So long as they aren’t laced with chemicals or sugars, all three plant-based milk substitutes mentioned earlier (oat milk, soymilk, and almond milk) are very healthy alternatives.
Apart from that, Half-and-Half can also be a healthy substitute for coffee milk because it has lower fat levels and sugar than the other alternatives.
Are there other alternatives for coffee milk?
We’ve put together the seven most effective alternatives to the milk used in coffee; however, it doesn’t mean they’re the only option for replacing the milk used in your coffee. There are many alternatives, particularly in the department of plant milk.
There’s a variety of nut milk on the market, including hazelnut and cashew milk. For grains-based dairy, rice and hemp milk are also great substitutes.
You can also utilize coconut milk that you can make to make your coffee. However, it’ll result in the coffee’s unique taste and texture.
If you want to substitute your milk with a dairy alternative, consider using goat’s milk. It can impart a slightly bitter taste, but it offers a range of benefits for your health, like more calcium levels than cow’s milk and higher levels of probiotics, which are beneficial to health.
Heya, I’m Norah! The foodie editor here at YummyTasteFood! I love absolutely everything to do with food, baking, and eating! I earned my stripes in the hospitality industry as a pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. I’m now a freelance writing nomad. I do not miss the hospitality industry! Be sure to join our Facebook group – it’s free to access!