Why Are My Brownies Cakey?

Why are my brownies cakey? Brownies are much more “cakey” when they have greater proportions of flour and less fat. It is also possible for brownie recipes to be more cake-like if they’re baked too long.

Everyone loves a great brownie, particularly ones that have an appealing soft and gooey texture. But , they’re not always made out that way even if you’ve baked the recipe thousands of times before!

Baking can be described as a scientific process and understanding the reason why certain events occur, particularly when they don’t go as planned can help you figure out what you can take to correct them.

One of the most significant “mistakes” that happens when baking brownies has to do with their texture.

The key to achieving the brownie you love is in the proportions. If your favorite brownie recipe came out too cakey this time It is likely that you overcooked it a bit.

For brownies that are moist make sure to bake them less or modify the recipe.

Today, we’ll take a looked at the distinctions between brownies that are cakey and fudgy. We will then discuss the specifics of how to accomplish one or the two. In addition, we will address a variety of frequently asked questions about brownie baking and other issues.

Cakey and Fudgy Brownies

Before you even begin to look at what influences the taste of brownies and the reason why they are made as it is, need to know what various kinds of brownies are to create the best ones.

Apart from the taste, what makes some brownies stand out from other brownies is the texture. Some brownies have more of a like a cake texture, while others are more chewy and fudge-like.

Fudgy brownies, also known as chewy brownies are more dense, softer and more moist than cakey brownies. This is due to the higher fat content. This results in a gooey, gooey feel that’s soft and luxurious.

Cakey brownies are made with a more substantial amount of flour compared to fudgy brownies. They will result in an effervescent and light exture. They contain smaller amounts of moisture due to the fact that they contain more flour and, consequently, are more dry (not necessarily in a good way).

Both are equally good (although there is a possibility that you be in disagreement!). It’s the matter of individual preference.

Naturally, it’s a problem for many when brownies turn out contrary to their preferred flavor. We can help you avoid that!

Why Do Brownies Turn Out Cakey?

After we’ve talked about how the different ingredients impact the texture of the brownies, it’s easy to comprehend why they turned out the way they did.

Brownies with a cakey texture are nearly always the result of the recipe and the ratio of the ingredients.

Recipes high in flour are usually intended for brownies that are cakey. If you’re not sure about what “high in flour” means make sure to check whether the recipe has baking powder or bicarbonate of soda.

If it is mean that they would like their texture to become soft so that they can make cake-like brownies.

recipes that are free of fat can produce cakey brownies. Fat can be found in the form of oil, butter chocolate, chocolate, and even milk.

A recipe that isn’t containing lots of liquid can have a cakey flavor. Recipes that contain lots of eggs is another sign that your brownie is cakey.

Also, over-baked brownies may also turn out cakey after you’ve taken out all moisture.

Can You Fix Cakey Brownies?

There’s no solution to fix cakesy brownies once they’ve been baked. Because the texture is dependent on the proportion of ingredients used included in the recipe once they’ve been cooked, there’s nothing you can do to alter the texture.

Even even if the ratios were right however, if the baking was too hot it is impossible to bring back the chewiness or Fudge-like texture.

The most effective way to do this is placing simple syrup or chocolate over the brownies while they’re in the middle of being hot. This will give them some moisture, but does not alter the cake-like texture.

You can also enjoy your brownies with Ice cream to counteract the dryness.

What is the effect on the texture of Brownies?

Now that you are aware of the differences between fudgy brownies and cakey brownies. We can take a look at the various factors that impact the texture.

Understanding the factors that create different textures, you’ll be able to determine what you require to create a particular texture or the best way to repair a broken one.

Fat and Flour

The simple brownie recipeconsists of flour, butter sugar, eggs, sugar chocolate, a rising agent and, occasionally, liquids like oil or milk.

The most significant factor that determines the brownies’ texture is fat. Fat can be used in the form of butter (which is comprised of made of fat) as well as chocolate (especially milk chocolate that has an extremely high percentage of fat).

Fat provides a lot of mouthfeel and moisture and is basically the base of every good brownie. The more fat that is present in the recipe, the more moist the brownie will be.


As we’ve mentioned that the more flour in a recipe the greater the quality of it will taste. This is due to the fact that flour absorbs the moisture from various other components. Therefore, if you want an incredibly cakey brownie it is essential to use lots of flour. Likewise, if you’re looking for a moist brownie you’ll need a little flour.

Other Ingredients

Baking soda , also known as baking powderare the most common raising agents that are commonly used in brownies. They are usually used in the cakey recipe brownies to to create a taller structure.

You don’t need a dry, heavy brownie but instead an airy and crumbly brownie.

Sugar doesn’t alter the texture of brownies unless you’re making use of the brown sugars, such as muscovado or Molasses. These sugars are very moist and consequently add moisture to the brownie.

“Sticky” sweeteners (like honey, muscovado or syrup) are sure to add tons of liquid as well as chewiness.

Milk and oil naturally will also give you moisture, however the proportion of these two ingredients will affect the taste of brownie. The more liquid you add to the brownie will produce a chewier and more fudgier brownie.

Baking Time

Along with the components, bake duration of brownies can also directly impact the levels of moisture. The longer a brownie bakes and the longer it bakes, the more moisture gets removed , and the more dry the item will be.

If you want chewy brownies, you won’t need to bake them too long. You may even need to underbake them. Cakey brownies bake for the whole time, if not a little longer.

A word of caution However, be cautious when trying to bake too much brownies. It is usually considered to be risky or even dangerous in order to consume uncooked or uncookedbaked items that contain eggs.

If we refer to them as undercooked, that’s the least duration of bake time which bakes your brownies. Like you can take cookies from the oven once they’re sticky or crispy, an additional few minutes could alter the brownies.

How to Avoid Cakey Brownies

There aren’t any solutions to repair cakey brownies there are plenty of ways to stop the cakey brownies from happening.

1. The majority of people over-bake their products. To prevent thisfrom happening, it is essential to be sure to follow the baking times precisely.

2. It is also important to be sure to check the oven’s temperature. A lot, if not all ovens are prone to uneven temperature and hot areas. Be sure to know the temperature of your oven before you use it.

In the event that your oven’s temperature is hotter than it should be (or cooler) then adjust the temperature to match. However, don’t alter the baking time!

If, for instance, your oven is overheated and you bake the brownies less and then bake them longer, all it can make happen is that it will over-bake the outside but under-bake inside. Instead, make your oven cooler and bake the proper duration.

3. In the event that your oven seems to be operating perfectly, the cakey brownies are because of the recipe. You can check recipes prior to making them or alter the recipe.

A cakey brownie will possess high levels of flour with low fat, and also a lower liquid content.

If you’d like to modify a cakey recipe to make an even more delicious brownie It is possible to do any of these:

  • Reduce the amount of flour in your diet.
  • Add more liquid.
  • You can add more fat or chocolate.
  • The brownies should be baked slightly under the oven.

You can try just one of these methods one at a time to make sure you don’t make any changes to the recipe! Make note of any modifications that you made to make improvements for the next batch!

How Do You Fix Uncooked Brownies?

There’s a distinction between undercooked and fudgy brownies. The brownies that have been cooked are usually left with the consistency of batter, whereas fudgy brownies have a distinct gooey texture.

Although you may love the fudgy brownies and baked goods that are moist There is something called too dry. Like with cakes that are not cooked properly You’ll need to cook the brownies you’ve cooked slightly more.

To remedy undercooked brownies put them back in the oven and bake for an additional 5 to 10 minute (depending on how fresh they are).

Again, it’s essential to ensure that your oven functions properly and that there aren’t unstable spots.

An oven that is running colder than what it is supposed to invariably cause brownies to become under baked So next time, increase the temperature a little higher.

Other Questions Asked

Why are My Brownies Flat?

Brownies aren’t cakes. A majority of people believe that they’re supposed to rise quite a bit. Brownies, in particular, those with fudgy ingredients, will rise only just a little.

However, if your brownies turn out very uneven, then it could be the result of mixing too much.

It is also possible to determine whether the recipe has baking soda or baking powder that are vital ingredients in cakey brownies as well as for baked goods to rise.

Another reason brownies can become very dense is because there is not enough sugar. By beating butter and sugar together, you’re adding air. Therefore, if you don’t add sweetener, the brownies be airless and lack structure.

Why Are My Brownies So Hard?

The hard brownies could be the result of several factors:

  • The brownies can be refrigerated at any time. The sugar crystals begin to harden and causes the texture to change in exactly the same. Refrigerators can also dry out baked items.
  • Your brownies were over baked and the brownies dried out completely. It’s best to under bake them just a little.
  • The brownies were cut when they were fully cooling, then you let them dry over the course of a few hours.

To soften brownies that are hard, you could try to put them in an oven that is preheated for a short time. This will melt the sugar crystals and give an attractive texture. It is recommended to spread a bit of butter over the top to bring the moisture.

Why did my brownies crack on the top?

This is the result of hitting the batter too hard and infusing too much air.

The air bubbles within the batter expand as the batter is baked after which, when it is removed from the oven, they shrink. As they shrink, they cause cracks on the top even causing in the center of the batter to sink.

Amy McKelvey

Amy McKelvey

Hey, I'm Amy, I'm one of the content editors at YummyTasteFood! I tend to spend my time thinking of how many cats I could next adopt... I also have a massive sweet tooth and love all things chocolate, cake, pudding, or dessert related!

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!