The Best Mac And Cheese Milk Substitutes

What are the best alternatives to milk to make mac and cheese?

Any milk-based or creamy product can be a good alternative to plain milk in mac and cheese. It doesn’t matter if it plant or animal-based. This includes dairy-based items like cream cheese, sour cream and yogurt. Coconut milk, almond milk and soy milk.

What could be more satisfying than a classic dish with homemade macaroni and cheddar? It’s a simple and quick dish to prepare, comes with many variations to the recipes, and is a fantastic and nutritious meal.

However, sometimes cheese and macaroni can be monotonous, repetitive, and boring and boring, so why not spice the flavor? The easiest method to add some variety is to change the flavor of the sauce, or substitute milk.

Today we will examine some of the most effective alternatives to milk used found in cheese and mac. We will look not only for their consistency or taste but also for the best way you can substitute them as well as other guidelines to remember when making the switch.

If you’ve not tried this mac and cheese that you can purchase on Amazon and it’s time to do so try it, it’s one of the best I’ve ever found.

What is Mac and Cheese

Mac and Cheese is a meal consisting of pasta cooked in macaroni and melty, creamy cheese sauce. It is stringy and stringy.

There are many variations of this dish based on the location you’re from. It is often served with extra grated cheese, or breadcrumbs to add crunch.

The sauce, as we see it is the main component of the dish. Mac and cheese are prepared using the mornay sauce. It is a fancy name for the cheesy bechamel sauce.

The process of making this sauce is simple it is as simple as mixing butter with flour to make a Roux (the ingredient that thickens the sauce) and then slowly adding milk and continue stirring the sauce until it is thick.

You then add your cheeses and then add these to your macaroni just before it bakes.

Here is the exciting is. When you use other ingredients in place of milk, you can add an entirely new taste to the meal.

Milk Substitutes for Mac and Cheese

Certain of these substitutions could react differently in the sauce and may require more roux. However, we’ll go over all of the above and much more.

1. Cream Cheese

Cream cheese is among the most effective alternatives to milk that you can locate. It has a light and slightly sweet flavor which is very similar to milk. This is what makes it a fantastic alternative.

The main difference between the two ingredients is their consistency. Cream cheese has a more dense and easily spreadable consistency. This is the reason it has the extra creaminess. It can make macaroni and cheese softer.

For cream cheese to be used as an alternative, substitute the milk for equal amounts of cream cheese. Due to its consistency, you are also able to cut out the butter. You’ll still get the most creamy, thick and extra-cheesy sauce!

It is possible to melt the cream cheese or soften it prior to when adding it to the sauce.

Here’s a fun suggestion for you to test different types of cream cheese as well as different flavors. We love using cream cheese with a herb flavor to make our macaroni and cheese. It provides a unique flavor without any additional effort!

2. Sour Cream

Sour cream is another excellent option for milk substitutes particularly if you are looking for similar textures, but an enhanced flavor.

It has a more dense consistency than milk and is slightly heavier than cream. It has a wonderful, tart, and almost sour (hence its name) flavor that is an interesting flavor to cheese and mac.

The milk can substitute for sour cream, in proportional amounts and the sauce is prepared exactly the same way.

The flavor, however, is definitely distinct from that of cream cheese which is less neutral and sweeter. It is possible to add other ingredients in order to get it to the same level.

To cut through an acidity in the sour cream You can add freshly chopped garlic or additional dried herb. It won’t alter the taste, it just makes it more balanced.

Sour cream is also utilized in conjunction with milk. It is possible to use half milk and half sour cream to create an enticing, balanced sauce as opposed to plain bechamel.

Sour cream is also substituted in Greek dairy-based recipes for mac and cheese. Sour cream and yogurt are quite similar in consistency and flavor, making them interchangeably.

3. Plain Greek Yogurt

Plain Greek yogurt is another efficient alternative. As we’ve mentioned earlier, plain yogurt and sour cream are similar in texture and consistency so they are interchangeable.

Plain yogurt can give you a more creamy sauce to cook your pasta in and it also gives that delicious tart flavor that is able to be altered.

Greek yogurt can produce more creamy and dense results when in comparison to regular low-fat, fat-free, or low-fat varieties.

The most important thing to keep in mind when making use of dairy in any dish that needs heating is to heat it gradually. If the yogurt is heated at a high rate it is likely for it to break (the fat and the water is split).

If you are making your sauce using yogurt, warm the yogurt in a separate pan over a double boiler, or very slowly in an extremely small pot before mixing it into the roux.

Be sure to stir constantly when you heat your yogurt. You should also utilize a low temperature in the making of the sauce.

4. Whipping Cream

There is no reason to be uneasy when substituting the cream with milk however make sure you use whipping cream. Whipping cream has a less dense texture than double cream and will blend into the roux more easily.

Naturally, it is possible to be able to whip and double cream in conjunction.

Making use of cream instead makes your macaroni and cheese creamier and more luscious. You can opt to not add butter, however, we would not skip it.

Be aware that the cream can reduce the color of cheese sauce If you like an orange mac and cheese, you should make sure you choose a brighter cheese, such as cheddar that is orange.

Double cream and whipping can be substituted by milk.

5. Coconut Milk

For a non-dairy and vegan alternative, coconut milk is an excellent alternative that is just as readily available as dairy-based substitutes.

Coconut milk is a delicious and distinct coconut taste, and it barely translates into baked mac and cheese. You will notice a distinct difference however, it won’t hit you on the cheek.

If you’re not a fan of coconut flavors then you can dilute it with water or add powerful aromatics like herbs or garlic. Also, we often employ coconut cream in place of coconut milk, which makes for more creaminess to the sauce.

Make sure to use coconut milk that is unsweetened and full-fat to get the best outcomes. We recommend canned coconut milk since they are typically thicker and creamy than bottle versions.

6. Almond Milk

Almond milk is a different accessible dairy-free milk that can be an ideal milk substitute for cheese and mac.

Similar to coconut milk or any other kind of milk, animal or plant-based, coconut milk is characterized by its almond-like or nutty flavor. It is something that you will either like or dislike however before you make the final decision it is a must to taste it with macaroni and cheese!

Almond milk is available in unsweetened and sweetened versions and the one you pick is up to you.

Personally, we prefer the sweetened versions of the macaroni and cheese dish since it is similar to the sweetness of milk – however, it’s up to you!

Almond milk is thinner than milk, which means it will not make a rich and creamy sauce. To overcome this, you could make additional Roux (flour and butter mix) as well as cheese.

Who doesn’t want to eat more cheese?

7. Soy Milk

Soy milk was among the first alternatives to dairy milk that was not dairy-based and, naturally, it’s excellent as a substitute for milk in cheese and mac also!

Soymilk has a distinct flavor that a lot of people do not like. However, when you balance it with other ingredients, it will satisfy all palates.

It is also possible to use an aromatic and fragrant cheese to create an extremely complex flavor profile.

Soymilk is naturally sweeter than milk, but it is close to milk in being consistent, it is not quite as sweet.

We suggest using unsweetened and unflavored milk. If you select soymilk that is vanilla-flavored is not going to go well with other flavors of cheese and macaroni.

It can create an unnatural sweetness, which is difficult to balance in pasta.

8. Additional Dairy-based Milks

We’re going to briefly look at milk derived from animals including sheep, goat, and camel milk.

All of these milk come with distinctive flavors that may not appeal to all people, but if you’re looking to try something new, and you’re in possession of these kinds of milk you should definitely give them a try! You might even discover a new favorite!

They generally are richer and less tangy than cow’s milk, however, their consistency is nearly identical. It is possible to substitute the milk with equal amounts and make the sauce exactly the same manner.

To reduce the taste that these types of milk have, thin it out with water, which is a neutral-tasting dairy, or even add aromas such as garlic, herbs, and spices.

Certain cheeses can neutralize the flavor. We would suggest replacing the milk (without adding any spices).

A lot of this milk, like goat’s milk, has less lactose which means that those who struggle with lactose intolerance may not have similar issues with these dairy products.

9. Evaporated or powdered milk

Powdered milk is an excellent alternative due to its long-lasting. It’s the perfect milk substitute if you have to replenish your milk.

Simply store a bottle that is powdered in the kitchen cupboard and you will be able to save yourself lots of anxiety.

Powdered milk is prepared by mixing dairy powder and regular drinking water. The mixture can be used later for making the sauce.

It generally creates edgier milk that is also less sweet in comparison to regular milk. The sweetness is balanced by the regular amounts of salt used in the recipe. It can be very tasty.

Evaporated milk refers to milk with a lower amount of water but it’s not in a powdered form. This type of milk could be used as to substitute or alternative, and could even perform much better than the powdered version.

It is sweeter in taste than powdered or regular milk. You may have to dilute or thin the flavor using regular water or milk or balance its flavor by mixing it in with various flavors.

Condensed milk is a sweetened variant of evaporated milk that has a syrup-like consistency. It isn’t recommended to make cheese and macaroni unless it’s been reduced.

We decided to speak about condensed milk simply because many people mistake it for evaporated milk.

10. Oat Milk

Regaining your balance by utilizing dairy-free milk alternatives, oatmeal milk is another favorite of ours.

We’ve had this type of milk once and we have to affirm that it’s tasty, filling, and is a fantastic alternative to dairy.

It’s more delicious than milk however, not much. In contrast to other nuts and cereal milk substitutes, this does not possess a distinctive and strong flavor.

In recipes using macaroni and cheese, it blends perfectly, and you’ll barely be able to tell! Similar to most options you should use the non-sweetened version to avoid an unbalanced dish.

11. Cashew Milk

The second milk that we recommend is made by blending cashews. It is a very creamy flavor that is neutral and milk-like and has a silky-smooth texture.

If used as a substitute for macaroni and cheese it will blend effortlessly and people will not even be aware of the difference.

You can make cashew milk just like you would regular milk but with equal amounts. Always choose an unsweetened, unflavored, and unflavored option to avoid strange tastes from developing.

Another thing to keep in mind that a lot of people tend to forget is that cashews are not nut-allergy-friendly. Individuals with allergies to nuts may be prone to an extreme allergic reaction.

12. Quinoa Milk

Quinoa milk is a less well-known plant-based milk, yet we believe there isn’t enough attention given to it. Naturally, it’s more difficult to find.

If you do have the chance to utilize it, your first dish is likely to be macaroni with cheese. The milk made from grains is made from quinoa seeds and water, in the same manner, that nuts milk is produced.

Quinoa milk is a slightly more sweet and nuttier taste that is distinctive from quinoa. In macaroni and recipes for cheese, its nutty taste is prominent and makes an exquisitely balanced flavor profile.

This milk is ideal when you’re planning to play around with cheese since the flavor of this milk is neutral to blend almost any flavor.

It is possible to substitute regular milk for quinoa milk in equal portions and prepare the macaroni sauce exactly the same way.

13. Rice Milk

Rice milk has an incredibly similar flavor to cow’s milk! You won’t detect the difference between cheese and macaroni and so will the guests you are bringing to your table.

Consistency is where the biggest difference is. Rice milk is less creamy and has the consistency of water.

This is easily corrected by adding more roux (the melting of butter and flour to thicken the sauce) or by adding additional cheese into the dish. The cheese helps to hold the sauce while making the creaminess.

14. Hemp Seed Milk

Hemp products are becoming more popular and extensively used, particularly in the everyday cooking of mac and cheese.

From a nutritional point of view, hemp seed milk can be healthy when compared to other hemp-based products.

Hemp seed milk has a distinct sweet and nutty taste, with some calling it earthy. It’s also quite rich and creamy and makes the sauce extra creamy when it is mixed with cheese.

If you are substituting hemp milk for the making of macaroni sauce, you will normally use a little less roux due to its consistency.

Once you’ve prepared the sauce, it’s possible to thin it out with water so that it is more spreadable however this is left to your own personal taste.

Another thing to make is that the flavor of the nuts can be unpleasant to those who are used and prefer milk with sweet varieties. You could add some syrup or sugar to ease the bitterness, but it’s entirely your decision.

15. Water or Butter

This is a last-resort alternative in the event that you do not have any of the substitutes mentioned above.

This process is more complicated as you must constantly monitor the consistency and taste that the dish has.

To make a delicious macaroni and cheese sauce, using butter and water, follow these steps:

  • Create a roux by mixing equal amounts of flour and butter. Then add water, and following that, the cheese.
  • Don’t make use of a huge amount of water! This can result in an unappetizing sauce that isn’t going to look appealing. The water is there to provide a basis for melting the cheese into.
  • Make use of the cheese as the primary liquid base, and also to make the sauce thicker and to create the perfect texture.
  • You must use quite lots of cheese and preferably the most melty varieties like cheddar and gouda. Avoid the soft varieties of cheese because they’ll be watery, and not hard.
  • When you’ve reached the desired consistency You can then add more butter to increase the richness of the sauce. Continue cooking until the right consistency is reached.
  • Be sure that you season the sauce carefully, since the liquid base may appear unappetizing (if you don’t have enough cheese or strongly flavor kinds).

Interesting Facts & Questions

What is a good substitute for butter for Mac and Cheese?

If you’re using butter in your mac and cheese dish, as an ingredient in the roux (the thickening agent) you must utilize an alternative. This can be margarine or Ghee and anything else that could aid in the process of thickening.

If you’re using butter to flavor your food and you want to add more richness or to alter the consistency you can substitute heavy cream or cream cheese, mascarpone, and melted ghee or margarine.

Can these substitutes be used with any variation of Mac and Cheese?

Like every recipe, and especially ones that have a variety of options, it’s essential to play around with the recipe.

All of the mentioned alternatives come with their own distinct flavor that may not match with another flavor.

For instance, we don’t like the use of almond milk when it comes to ground mac and cheese from beef however, we do like soy milk in combination with it.

Be sure to note down notes whenever you substitute ingredients and then reference them so that you are able to make improvements to the recipe and adjust it to your individual preferences.

Are these substitutes nutritious?

It’s a tough question to answer, yet it’s an often-asked question. It all depends on what you think the definition of healthy is.

For many, cow’s milk doesn’t have any nutritional value and can trigger severe inflammation however to some, it’s a vital component of their daily nutritional requirements.

Generally speaking, milk products made from animals have a high content of minerals and vitamins. The plant-based milk doesn’t usually have as many nutrients due to the fact that they’re often separated (which eliminates tons of nutrition) and then diluted with water.

Before you make any substitution be sure to know the ingredients and whether it is compatible with your personal requirements for dietary supplements.

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.