Can You Refreeze Melted Ice Cream?

Can you refreeze melting ice cream? Although you are technically able to refreeze melted ice cream you shouldn’t. Ice cream is among the few food items that shouldn’t refreeze. Since it is made of eggs, dairy, and sometimes eggs the chance of contracting listeria as well as other bacteria is extremely high!

It’s it is easy to overlook the tub of ice cream that you took out for your barbecue in the backyard, only to come across it when it’s a melting mess. It’s a waste to toss the entire tub in the trash. So you may want to store it in the freezer.

It’s not just an issue with food safety however, the ice cream might not have the same flavor and texture after it has been thawed and refrozen.

It is best to watch the ice cream that you are serving to make sure it isn’t melting or dispose of the ice cream that has gone to pieces. But, there are a few circumstances that aren’t so bad, so continue reading to learn how, and if, you can ever refreeze your ice cream.

Why You Shouldn’t Refreeze Melted Ice Cream Melted

It’s not worth the effort to refreeze the cream that is already melting completely. There are too many dangers that are involved, and the taste, as well as the quality of the cream, will be sourer.

These are the three major reasons you shouldn’t refreeze melting ice cream:

1. It’s Not Safe

The ice cream you buy is a dairy product and may contain eggs. If it is left at temperatures of room temperature or within a hot place for a long time there’s a high possibility of dangerous bacteria will begin to multiply.

Since ice cream is first frozen, it could take some time for the process to occur, but it is certain to occur if the ice cream is exposed to sunlight for a couple of hours, or left at temperatures that are too cold for a prolonged period.

One of the major issues is listeria which could cause serious food poisoning.

2. The Texture Changes

When the ice cream has been frozen for its first-time crystals of ice form that are uniform and tiny. After the ice cream is refrozen, more crystals of ice begin to form. this results in a coarse texture that can be quite unappealing to eat.

The ice cream is more of a finely crushed ice, rather than rich, creamy ice cream.

3. Loss Of Air

Air is turned into ice cream once it is created, via the process of churning. This makes the ice cream have a soft, creamy texture.

The moment ice cream is melting, the air that was stirred into it disappears, and refreezing the cream transforms it into the form of a thick block that must be re-churned to bring back the air.

Can I Refreeze Ice Cream That Has Partially Thawed?

If the ice cream is placed out, but in a cooler environment but hasn’t been completely melted, it’s acceptable to freeze it. It is essential to check that there are crystals of ice in the cream or that it is still frozen in a portion.

This means that the texture doesn’t alter too much once it’s refrozen and there isn’t too much air that has been lost. There may be a little alteration in the texture and the lightness of the cream but this will not be as dramatic as if the ice cream was completely melted, and then was refrozen.

There’s also a lesser likelihood of growth of bacteria in the case of ice cream that was kept at a cool temperature since bacteria, including the most the dreadful listeria, can only develop rapidly when temperatures are warmer or at room temperature.

It is up to your own judgment as to whether the ice cream is defrosted enough to be frozen again, however it is recommended to be careful.

If in doubt, simply throw it away and get a fresh tub! It’s not worth being sick and eating an ice cream that simply isn’t what you want!

Can I Refreeze Ice Cream Left Out Overnight?

Do not allow Ice cream to sit outside of your fridge or freezer all night, no matter how warm the temperature!

Bacteria can grow quickly when temperatures are between 40 to 140 degrees Fahrenheit and ice cream shouldn’t be stored in these temperatures for more than 2 hours.

When serving ice cream, only leave it out for less than two hours and then put it back in the freezer, if it hasn’t fully defrosted. This is the same for homemade Ice cream as well!

It’s possible to refreeze the ice cream you’ve stored in the refrigerator overnight, however, you must check the extent to which it has defrosted when the morning arrives.

Ice cream is melted quickly at room temperature and is not required to be kept out for a long time for it to completely melt. The mixture of sugar, milk, and other liquids found in the ice cream creates the perfect environment for the growth of bacteria at higher temperatures.

This is more serious if you’ve been making ice cream out of the tub with the wrong spoon, which isn’t free of dirt. The bacteria are being introduced to the cream which is just going to keep multiplying!

What Can I Eat Melted and Then Refreezed Ice Cream?

It is possible to consume the ice cream refrozen and then melted but it is not recommended. It’s not worthy of the possibility of food poisoning or listeria that you could contract, and it’s best to stay clear of it.

You’re not just at risk of getting sick, but also the texture the taste, and the quality of the ice cream aren’t worth the risk and will prove to be a bit disappointing. Instead, just scoop a spoonful from the ice cream that is properly frozen, and put it right back into the freezer.

This means you don’t run the risk of the ice cream breaking in the process, only to refreeze it. It also ensures that the ice cream you purchase will be of the highest quality when you return for more!

How Can You Tell When Ice Cream Has Melted and Refrozen?

If you’re not sure if the ice cream is refrozen or melted You can check its texture cream. If it’s quite coarse with lots of ice crystals and when the ice cream appears thick and not airy, it’s likely been refrozen.

Ice cream that has been kept for too long may also contain crystals of ice on its surface. In addition, the cream will begin to lose its creamy texture.

If the ice cream has become dense and grainy due to its age or from melting and refrozen, avoid eating it anyway.

How Can You Tell If Ice Cream Is Now Bad?

It’s not easy to determine if frozen food has gone bad, however, there are a few methods to determine if your ice cream is gone.

Ice cream that has been stored sitting too long can form ice crystals on its surface. They will also appear very grainy. It will be devoid of its creamy, rich consistency, and also.

There is also the scent of Ice cream. If it has an odd smell or a strange flavor, you need to dispose of it immediately.

It’s easier to pick the smells and flavors when the ice cream is defrosted slightly and if you’re not sure, allow it to soften before having a scent or a taste.

Other Questions Asked

How Long Will Frozen Ice Cream That Is Not Opened Keep Within The Freezer?

If stored in its original packaging, in its sealed and sealed, ice cream could last for as long as 12 months. It must be maintained at a temperature of 0°F.

How long the ice cream will last is contingent on the storage conditions. So the more efficiently it is stored the longer it’ll last.

Is It Safe To Eat Ice Cream After It Expires?

It is generally permissible to consume the ice cream after the expiration date, provided there is no evidence of spoilage. The package of ice cream must have a best before date or a best before date or best used by date, but they don’t usually signify the date of safety.

These dates provide an estimation of when the quality of ice cream will be at its best and when the quality will start to diminish after this date. This does not indicate that the product will be spoiled following this date.

How Long Can Ice Cream Keep In The Freezer?

Ice cream should never be stored in the freezer for more than 2 hours. If it’s been out for more than that, it must be removed.

Refreezing Ice-Cream

It is not recommended to freeze ice cream after it has been thawed, or melted completely.

There is a possibility of bacterial growth and foodborne illnesses like listeria. Ice cream can also be spongy and disappear in its smooth texture.

It’s okay to refreeze ice cream when it’s just partially thawed. However, make sure to consider whether the ice cream is safe to refreeze!

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!