Scone vs Biscuit – What’s The Difference?

What is the difference between a biscuit and a scone? The main differences are in their textures and their flavors: biscuits are generally soft and flaky, tending towards savory by themselves, whereas the scones are more crumbly and are usually intended to be sweet.

If you ask anyone in the UK what the difference between a scone versus a biscuit would be, they’ll most likely define scones as something that appears like an American biscuit and describe the word “biscuit” as similar to the American cookie.

In the United States, biscuits and scones are two kinds of fast-baked bread, which means they need baking soda or even powder to allow the dough to rise rapidly when it is cooked. You won’t need to worry about how much yeast you will need as it isn’t included in the recipes.

There are many other variations However, there are many other differences. We’ll go over everything from ingredients to texture as well as baked-in and post-baked add-ons and toppings and the form.

What Is A Scone?

The classic scone is the place the story starts. Scones first appeared in Scotland in the 1500s. This was long before America, in the way we think of it today.

Original recipes were created out of Oats, which were then which were rolled into a massive loaf, which was divided into triangular pieces and cooked over a fire.

As time went by and they moved to the south of England, People gradually began to prepare them using dough and baking them with the help of ovens. Dried fruits like currants and raisins were also added.

They were usually served with preserves and clotted cream (jam). Even to this day, there’s an oddly fierce debate about how to place the clotted cream on first, before putting on the jelly on top, or in reverse.

As time passed, British and Scottish settlers brought their food across the New World, which was modified enough to qualify as legally American.

American Scone

European Scones were changed closer into American biscuits during the South and we’ll be discussing them in a second.
However, Northern Americans were less concerned with the ingredients that would go under their food and were more focused on their tea and coffee-time snacks.

So Scones in America are in some ways like scones from the UK. They’re crumbly and sweet and the perfect choice for coffee breaks. Even savory scones can be enjoyed with some sweetness.

A perfect American scone is largely soft and moist but not too heavy. The outside is a little crunchy. It is also easy to break into pieces.
While biscuits are known for their buttery taste Scones make use of a lot greater butter when making them. However, they’re offset by an additional amount of sugar and that’s the reason why scones are known due to their sweetness.

They’re typically coated with sweet icing to add a little sweetness.

How Are Scones Eaten In America?

Scones are usually eaten as a stand-alone item. They aren’t necessarily eaten along with other foods. They’re quite dense and can be used as a snack alternative.

One of the biggest distinctions between biscuits and scones is that scones can be flavorful with fruit or savory ingredients, such as cheese or herbs, whereas biscuits tend to be more simple.

Scones are a great way to make an individual dish.

They’re simple to pack and carry on your journey without having to think about anything else other than the beverage you prefer.

Why Is My Scones Hard?

There could be a variety of reasons why your scones have become hard; however most likely causes are any of the following:

You’ve over-mixed your dough Instead of making use of a food processor or blender, you can use the pastry cutter to create your dough.

You’ve used too much liquid This might sound odd, but using too much buttermilk, or any other liquid, can make tough scones, only use enough to make your ingredients stay together.

You have overbaked your scones – Take your scones out of the oven when the bottoms only begin to turn golden brown. As Mary Berry would say, you don’t want a soggy bottom!

What Is The Best Way To Make Moist Scones?

To ensure that your Scones are moist and light, start by using the correct ingredients. Cold butter can help raise scones, allowing the space needed for light, airy moisture. It is also important to weigh your flour according to weight, not volume.

Too much flour could make your scones dense instead of moist and cake-like.

The excess of something is not suitable for scones. Be careful with your salt, and remember that self-rising flour has salt, as well as liquids and sugar, particularly if you’re adding fruits already.

Keep watch on the baking process, and be careful not to overcook the cookies. When they’re done then, take them out of the oven.

What Is A Biscuit?

Regarding appearance In terms of appearance, biscuits from America appear closer to a typical British scone.
In America However, in America, you’re more likely to see them covered in gravy rather than clotted creme.

The South is well-known for its love for tasty, delicious meals. If you’re learning cooking in one of the states in the south You’ll likely be told to “add more butter or lard” and perhaps, “swap in some buttermilk or heavy cream.”

This is what occurred when scones of the UK were compared to with the American South, and a new recipe was created: it’s the biscuit.

The presence of fat in the mix will add weight, volume as well as flakiness. A great biscuit won’t break but it melts in your mouth before flaking into perfectly layered layers.

Rolled Biscuits

Biscuits are delicate, and they must be handled with care if you wish for them to rise adequately. When you’re rolling the dough, gently knead it and move fast.

The more you work with your dough the warmer it’ll be, and this will cause the ingredients to react before when they should be in the oven. It is important to keep your dough to be as chilled as you can until it reaches the oven that is preheated.

It is also important to ensure that you aren’t activating the gluten that happens when you over-work your dough. The more you work your dough the more difficult it is likely to be.

If you’re rolling into your biscuit, need the round cutter to create an outline of the biscuit.

If you bake many cookies you might be habitually pushing the dough into the cutter and then wiggle it to move the dough. Do not do this to your biscuits.

Cut through the dough. Remove your cutter from the dough. Any other method will prevent them from rising properly. the perfect biscuit must rise. If not, you’ll be slipping towards the territory of scone.

How Are Biscuits Eaten In America?

Biscuits are usually consumed warm, with the meal. They’re typically coated with gravy or butter however when they’re removed from the oven, some will probably be eaten without hesitation making additions.

Biscuits are also great alternatives for English Muffins for breakfast sandwiches and fast-food eateries in the south have altered their menus to accommodate this.

They’re typically served in conjunction with meals and breakfast and aren’t typically an individual product. Breakfast is usually served with jelly or eggs, sausages, or sausage gravy.

At dinner, you’ll find them at the table to scoop up macaroni and cheese dishes, casseroles, or the gravy made from fried chicken.

The leftover biscuits are of mythological origin, but should you stumble across one, there is a belief that they are great for croutons.

Are Biscuits Unhealthy?

Biscuits aren’t considered to be healthy.

There are, however, worse food items you can consume. When eaten in moderation, they’re unlikely to cause immediate health issues in the event of an allergy to food or intolerance.

The majority of biscuits and scones, in particular, are made with refined flour of wheat which is widely known to be a reason for a myriad of health problems over the long term. Sugars like white sugar and other sweeteners also warrant cautiousness.

On the flip side though, they’re delicious.

What makes Biscuits Fluff?

They require a mixture of two elements: warm butter (or other fat) and a warm oven.

Whenever you’re making bread dough, you want to start with a cold fat and cut it into your flour with a tool specifically made for blending dough (this is our top dough cutter).

It is recommended to make small pea-sized pieces before mixing in the tiny volume of liquid. Don’t overmix.

The butter should remain solid after it is placed in the preheated oven. If it melts before when it is baked it can hinder the proper rising and create hard crumbly biscuits.

The temperature of your oven is what will melt your butter and allows it to steam, resulting in volume.

What is the difference between Scones or Muffins?

The main distinction between muffins and scones in America is the way they’re made. Scones are triangular sweetbread, whereas muffins are more akin to small cakes with a dense texture.

Scones are made with dough, which is mostly white dough. Muffins are made with batter and may contain various ingredients. They can be made with varying levels of sweetness and fruitiness based on the particular recipe.

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!