7 Best Amaro Nonino Substitutes

If you are looking for the best Amaro Nonino substitutes, you’ve found the best guide for a fast and easy answer. Amaro is a unique kind of liqueur that’s not readily available. Amaro Nonino is a distinctive and flavorful type and is among the most expensive options available.

What are the most suitable alternatives to Amaro Nonino? We recommend finding a substitute in this same class, Amaro. The top choices in this category are Amaro Averna, Amar Meletti, or Amaro Tosolini. If you’re still not in a position to locate the right substitute Try Cynar as well as Cynar 70. Gammel Dansk Vermouth, Chartreuse, Bonal Gentaine Quina as well as Angostura bitters.

If you are unable to locate the bottle you’re looking for, want to invest a large sum for a particular kind of liqueur, or you’re in a bind and require a bottle, there are plenty of alternatives that you can pick from.

In this post, we’ll look at the numerous alternatives to Amaro Nonino. We will not only talk about the different types of substitutes, but also their distinct flavors, the reasons they are great alternatives, and how to utilize them.

Amaro Nonino BreakdownTaste and Flavor
AppearanceA golden clear, amber liqueur, with a coppery tint.
AromaA very concentrated citrus scent, with notes of spice, herbs, and, occasionally, caramel.
Taste / Flavor ProfileMango Citrus, Apricot, Mango, and Pepper. Allspice, Licorice, Caramel (or sometimes burned caramel), Vanilla, Honey
AftertasteThe caramel is a perfect aftertaste, with subtle spice hints.
The availabilityIt is very difficult to locate.
PriceExtremely expensive because of the intricate flavor profile, manufacturing method, and the difficulty of finding.

The Best Substitutes for Amaro Nono

Once you know the meaning behind this liqueur you can pick substitutes that are in accordance with the flavor you’re looking to substitute.

For instance, if you’re looking to substitute the citrus flavor of Amaro Nonino You can select a substitute with citrus flavor as well. If you want to replace the peppery flavor try a liqueur that is pepper-based.

7 of The Best Substitutes to Amaro Nonino

And, as a matter of due, here’s our list of the top 7 alternatives to Amaro Nonino Liquor!

1. Alternative Amaro Liqueurs

Before using any other substitute, we would highly suggest making use of an alternate Amaro or Amari Liquor.

Similar to how you substitute one whiskey for another prior to grabbing a red wine. This same concept applies to this. All Amaro liquors, despite having distinct characteristics, are produced in similar methods and styles, and also have the same flavors.

There are, however, a variety of kinds to choose from, so we’d suggest using Amaro Averna, Amar Meletti, or Amaro Tosolini.

Amaro Averna is arguably the closest to the flavor and features. Similar to Amaro Nonino Amaro Averna, it also is a strong citrus flavor with some caramel. It also has subtle spice and herb notes.

In general, Amaro Averna is sweeter and has a more syrup-like consistency and an alcohol content of 29 percent.

All of these are important things to think about when employing the substitute but, you could use the 1:1 ratio for the initial.

Amaro Meletti closely resembles the caramel and spices of Amaro Nonino. It also is characterized by a distinct bitterness from the herbaceous in it. Amaro Meletti additionally has a high alcohol content of around 32 percent.

Not the least last, Amaro Tosolini also contains a distinct citrus flavor as well as the distinctive bitterness that is characteristic of Amaro Nonino.

Amaro Tosolini does however have an extremely dark amber and burgundy hue that can affect the look of the products you are creating.

2. Cynar

Cynar is another kind of Italian Amaro but we did not include it in the sub-category of alternatives.

It is due to the fact that it is quite different from the previous Amaro.

Cynar is a blend of 13 different plants and herbs. One of the plants that make the majority of the flavor is artichoke, which seems like a surprise isn’t it?

However, it’s not a taste of artichokes. In fact, it doesn’t taste like it. It is a clear orange flavor and the taste of bitter chocolate.

Cynar only has 16.5 percent alcohol content and has an extremely deep dark brown hue.

If you’re looking for a better alternative to the regular Cynar and you are looking for a different one, try Cynar 70. Cynar 70 comes with a greater alcohol proof which means it is a great deal more flavor.

It is a lot more complex and darker flavor in comparison to the original Cynar Liquor. The flavor is like coffee and dark chocolate, with some orange.

3. Gammel Dansk

Gammel Dansk is an extremely well-known Danish bitter made from around 29 spices and herbs. It’s a remarkably rich and fragrant spirit that is an excellent alternative to Amaro Nonino.

Some of the most well-known flavors that pop up are cinnamon star anise (similar to Licorice) ginger, and Seville orange.

Although it is extremely bitter and spiced. However, it has fruity and sweet notes that make it a great alternative to Amaro Nonino.

This liqueur comes in a light golden brown hue that’s quite similar to Amaro Nonino which means it won’t alter color of drinks or baked goods much or at all.

4. Vermouth

In all honesty, it isn’t the best substitute for Amaro Nonino. It’s nevertheless accessible and inexpensive in comparison to many other alternatives.

Vermouth, even though it is an alcohol-based liqueur (whereas Amaro Nonino is grain-based) however, has very similar flavors and can easily be substituted. They include intense citrus flavors as well as other spices such as star anise and allspice.

There are numerous varieties of vermouth that are available So, so take a close look at the ingredients that are used in your particular bottle or the brand you prefer.

The primary types of citrus are citrus, lemon-lime, and sometimes pomelo peels.

Some of the most well-known herbs are oregano, juniper, ginger, lavender, flowers, and rosemary. The most popular spices comprise stars anise and allspice cloves, cinnamon, cardamom, and vanilla.

As you can observe, there are plenty of flavor affinities between these two liquors.

5. Chartreuse

Chartreuse is different and well-known alcohol that can be a much easier alternative. It’s French alcohol that comes in a wide range of flavors and hues.

Chartreuse regardless of the kind has a complex flavor profile made up of a variety of plants, herbs along with other ingredients. When compared with Amaro Nonino, it is a more spicy and earthy taste profile and is not as bitter.

The two most popular varieties are the green Chartreuse along with yellow Chartreuse.

Green Chartreuse has a significantly higher alcohol proof of 110 (which is equivalent to 55 percent ABV). It’s much more flavor-packed and aromatic than yellow Chartreuse.

Green Chartreuse is made of approximately 130 varieties of spices, herbs, and even plants.

Yellow Chartreuse only has an ABV of 80 (40 percent ABV), which is higher than Amaro Nonino. It has a milder taste and a sweeter taste as compared to the green version of Chartreuse.

Whichever you choose ensure that you are aware of the intense flavor as well as the color variation and the alcohol percentage into account when replacing it.

6. The Bonal Gentaine Quina

The liqueur has a wine base that has been fortified. This base has been infused with spices and herbs making it a more rich flavor profile.

Bonal also has quina which provides this liqueur with a bitter taste that is comparable to vermouth and many varieties of Amari.

It is a very dark brown-olive hue that can alter the color of your final product.

It shares a lot of flavors like Amaro Nonino such as licorice and citrus. The main distinction is the strong cherry flavor that the wine has something that Amaro Nonino lacks.

But, a lot of people including us, still love this alternative.

7. Angostura Bitters

A lot of individuals are acquainted with a particular product. These bitters are very popular for many mixed drinks, not just cocktails.

This is a highly concentrated alcoholic liquid that is made up of predominantly herbs. You only require just a few drops for the most potent and powerful taste. Its alcohol content is approximately 44.7 percent which is incredibly high.

The most similar flavor that exists between Amaro Nonino along with Angostura bitters is those of clove and cinnamon flavor that is closely associated with the pepper, star anise, and allspice.

What Is Amaro Nonino?

Amaro Nonino is a type of Italian Amaro. Amaro refers to “little bitter” in Italian and describes this particular drink precisely.

Other varieties of Amaro (also often referred to as Amari) are Aperol, Averna, and Campari. The primary difference between them Amaro Nonino and Amaro Nonino can be seen in the method the amaro is produced as well as their flavor as well as their pricing and availability.

Amaro Nonino is made with grappa and is infused with a variety of botanicals, herbs as well as fruits. This gives a gorgeous bittersweet taste profile that is extremely complicated.

A lot of people are aware of fruity flavors such as mango and citrus. The predominant spice flavors that pop out are allspice and pepper and the licorice (possibly from star anise or fennel).

Other flavors that are frequently not mentioned include honey caramel, vanilla, honey, and cocoa.

Amaro Nonino is distinctive because it has more exciting flavors than other liqueurs of the same type, and it has a lower sweetness also.

It is also evident the fact that this amaro has a larger ABV (alcohol in volume) percentage than other Amaro. While Aperol is amaro with an ABV of 11%. Amaro Nonino has a similar figure of 35 percent.

The most significant issue has to do with the fact that Amaro Nonino is extremely difficult to locate and, even if you locate it, it could be very expensive!

Did you find this guide helpful?
Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!