Best Retro Toasters – Buying Guide [2023]

A retro-styled, retro-looking toaster brings much to your kitchen. It has a classic design, but with new features, this kitchen appliance is stunning and useful.

What is the top retro toaster? The top retro toaster comes with adequate dimensions to fit on your counter. It is made of durable materials with slots large enough to accommodate a range of bread types and has any desired setting. Also, it should have the ability to adjust the browning level.

When choosing a retro toaster, there are some things to consider apart from appearance and color. You’ll need to be aware of the small details too. Remember: the higher the toaster levels, the more stories it has.

If you’ve been looking for a vintage toaster but haven’t been able to decide, then this article is ideal for you. Find out more about the top retro toasters.

Vintage Toasters: What Should You Think About

The answer lies in style if you’re thinking about what’s different with retro toasters. The majority of the time, they are identical to regular toasters. They have a retro, nostalgic style, distinguishing them from other toasters.

Retro toasters typically come in pastel shades. Retro toasters in white and red are popular as well.

A retro-inspired look to your kitchen could be the main reason you choose these toasters. But there are other factors to take into consideration.

Toaster Dimensions

It is not common for people to purchase a fashionable retro toaster only to store it in the kitchen cabinet. If you plan show it off, be sure you buy an oven that can fit nicely on your counter.


The material used to build the body of the toaster is vital. If you’re in a large family and require lots of bread toasted during the day, consider purchasing a toaster that has stainless steel bodies as it isn’t hot after a long time in toasting your bread.

Slots Dimensions

The width and length of the slots are essential aspects of the toaster. If you enjoy toasting bagels and various kinds of breads that are artisan, then choosing an old-fashioned toaster with broad slots is the best choice.

The size of the slots also varies according to the dimensions of the toaster, and it’s worthwhile to look into all dimensions.

Toast Levels

Select a retro-style toaster with different toasting levels or browning levels for perfect results regardless of how toasted you’d like your bread to taste.

Other features

Other things to consider are the precise settings of the toaster, whether it comes with an accessible crumb tray or not, and whether the lever is automated or manual, and so on.

3 Best Retro Toasters

Three of the most retro toasters you will buy. There is no reason not to choose one of these:

SortProductKey Features
1.KEEMO Small-sized Toaster RetroTwo slots and 6 levels of browning, 10.2x7x6.3.”
2.2 Slice Toaster from the pastTwo slots and 5 levels of browning, 18.5×15.3×11.3.”
3.Smeg Retro Toaster2-slots, six levels of browning, 12.7×7.6×7.7.”

Continue reading to learn more about these beautiful toasters reminiscent of the old days!

1. KEEMO Retro Small Toaster

Check the Current Cost at Amazon

Principal Features:

  • Bagel, defrost, as well as cancel functions
  • One-touch buttons that flash when they are pressed
  • Space for cords to store easily
  • Automatic pop-up
  • Time control and toast shade
  • Easy-reach lever

If you’re looking for an old-fashioned coffee maker with simple design and small size, and a small footprint, then the KEEMO small, retro-styled toaster is sure to please.

This toaster is small. It is able to hold two large slices of bagel or bread.

The body is made of steel, making this toaster a durable addition for your kitchen appliances collection. It’s rust-free and simple to clean due to the crumb tray that is a removable and smooth surface.

2. Nostalgia Wide 2-Slice Toaster

Check the Current Cost at Amazon

The Key Features:

  • Two extra-wide slots
  • Bagel defrost, bagel, and cancel buttons
  • Cord storage to make a stylish countertop in the kitchen
  • The preferred browning level (1 through 5)
  • A timer that auto-adjusts automatically
  • Easy to clean, thanks to the tray’s sliding design.

Are you searching for the most retro-styled toaster available you can find? Here’s the one. This vibrant red Nostalgia toaster is sure to steal your heart. White sides and stainless steel elements complete the look, making this toaster an unmistakably retro design.

The top layer of the toaster is plastic; it helps make the toaster light.

If you enjoy toasting not just bread but also bagels and muffins, The wide 1.5-inch thick slots are perfect for you.

3. Vintage Toaster Smeg SMEG 50’s

Check Prices for Amazon

The Key Features:

  • Automatic pop-up
  • Control knob that has six browning settings
  • Steel bread lift made of stainless steel
  • Reheat, defrost, and a bagel setting
  • Non-slip shoes
  • Touch release the crumb tray

If you’re willing pay more for a traditional but top-quality toaster, then Smeg toasters are worth a look into.

But the design isn’t the only thing that sells these toasters. They’re also constructed well and robust, with most steel construction.

Furthermore, toasters are available in a variety of colors. There is a toaster that matches your kitchen’s style.

The Smeg 50s style toasters come with all the features you require. However, what drives people mad over them is their timeless style. Toasters that are stylish as well as retro and stylish in equal measure.

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!