Can You Freeze Chicken Salad?

Can you freeze chicken salad? If you freeze mayonnaise and Greek yogurt, it is likely to separate when it is thawed, which could alter the appearance of your salad. But adding some more mayonnaise or Greek yogurt can make it taste better once thawed.

The chicken salad can be described as a timeless ingredient in the kitchen because it tastes great and is extremely adaptable.

Based on your chicken base with mayo (or Greek yogurt), you can incorporate various other ingredients to create an original and delicious dish that pleases your palate.

The process of making chicken salad is simple, and with the rise of batch cooking to cut down on your time, you could make more salad chicken in the kitchen than you could take in a few days.

With all the leftovers, you’re probably wondering best method of storing the chicken salad.

Read on to find out if you can freeze different kinds of chicken salad, the best way to freeze them, other ways to keep it in storage, and how to create the most delicious chicken salad you’ve ever had!

Can You Freeze Chicken Salad With Mayo?

A well-known method of making chicken salad is to blend chopped or shredded chicken with mayonnaise and various ingredients and seasonings.

Mayo is a great way to tie the chicken and all the other ingredients and creates the perfect, creamy flavor and texture.

However, can you freeze chicken salad that’s been prepared using mayonnaise? The first step is to know what mayo is and what it does during the freezing process.

Mayo is an emulsified food that is, and it blends two fats and liquids that they do not naturally would prefer and is done using a specific method.

For making mayonnaise, you’ll need the essential ingredients:

  • Oil
  • Eggs (whole or yolk, depending on the recipes or brand)
  • Vinegar or lemon
  • A little mustard

What you need to do to create mayonnaise is mix the oil with egg yolk to make the thick, creamy sauce.

The texture is distinct from sauces made using oil-like vinaigrettes because it’s thicker. After all, the oil gets mixed with eggs to make the most solid, creamy sauce.

If you freeze mayonnaise, the oil may be separated when it is thawed. This leaves you with something oily, not creamy. So, to get the best quality chicken salad, you should not keep it in the freezer.

Here are some ways to thaw your frozen chicken salad to enhance its texture.

I like adding another spoonful of mayonnaise and an ounce of Dijon mustard in the salad of chicken that is thawed and mixed it all in.

Adding more mustard and mayonnaise that have been emulsified can aid in emulsifying the oil back in the mix of chicken salad, resulting in a better texture.

It’s not absolute, but it can make the chicken salad more appealing.

Can you freeze Chicken Salad with Greek Yogurt?

Greek yogurt is an excellent alternative if you want to prepare the chicken salad you love with some spice. It’s packed with flavor, protein, and extremely creamy due to those healthy fats.

It gives my chicken salad a bit more flavor than mayo because of the process of fermentation that yogurt undergoes before eating.

Like mayo, which is prone to separating after thawing, Greek yogurt has a similar problem.

Since it’s a mixture of liquid and fat and does not go through the same emulsification process as mayonnaise, these two ingredients can separate when frozen and then thawed.

So, can you freeze your chicken salad that has Greek yogurt? The distinct texture of thawed Greek yogurt might be unpleasant to some people, so the idea of freezing your salad with chicken might not be ideal.

As with your chicken salad topped with mayonnaise, you can try mixing in a bit of Greek yogurt and Dijon mustard once it has thawed to mix the separated yogurt back into the salad.

It may not be a perfect fit, and some people may not appreciate the texture even when you add yogurt to the chicken salad.

Best Methods To Freeze Your Chicken Salad

Although it might not be a good idea to store your chicken salad for freezing when it’s made using mayonnaise or Greek yogurt, you may attempt it. In this article, I’ll explain the steps to freeze it and other methods you can employ to reduce cooking time.

How to Freeze Leftover Chicken Salad

If you’ve prepared an enormous portion of chicken salad, and you’re not sure you’ll be able to finish it all before it goes bad in the refrigerator, try freezing it.

Make sure that you choose mayonnaise or Greek yogurt base; it could split upon thawing, so adding additional amounts of either the frozen product after it has thawed will give you a more pleasant texture.

  1. Make sure to divide your chicken salad into portions you’ll need to eat after thawing. Don’t keep it frozen in a large lump, as you may not be enough to eat it after the frozen has been thawed.
  2. Choose freezer containers or containers that will fit your portion’s size. It is important to leave 1/3 of the container empty because it will grow when frozen.
  3. Place the salad of chicken into the freezer bag, then gently squeeze out any air, then seal. If you’re using a container, put the chicken salad inside the container, then press the plastic wrap on the top of the mix prior seal the lid.
  4. Use a piece of masking tape and mark the date and the contents onto it.
  5. Put it in your freezer, and take it out within 3 months.

How to Freeze Chicken in Batches Salad

If you haven’t yet added mayonnaise or Greek yogurt to your chicken salad, then you should comply with these instructions to freeze it.

  1. Mix in your shredded chicken, as well as any other spices, as well as any vegetables with low water content (avoid freezing celery or cucumber because they become soupy after they’ve been thawed).
  2. The chicken mix you have prepared should be divided into portions that you’ll need to eat within a couple of meals.
  3. Mix the chicken salad (minus mayonnaise as well as Greek yogurt) in freezer bags or containers that can be sealed.
  4. In the case of a freezer bag then, gently squeeze out any air pockets to avoid freezing burn, and then close the bag. To seal containers, put the plastic wrap directly onto the top of the chicken mix and then put the lid in place.
  5. Note the date and the content on the tape to remind you of what you frozen and the date you froze it, to avoid eating a chicken salad that’s turned bad.
  6. Place on the shelf for up to 3-6 months.
  7. If you’re looking to consume this chicken salad, defrost it in the refrigerator overnight before mixing it in with yogurt or mayonnaise and any watery veggies like celery, cucumbers, or even celery. Enjoy!

What Kind of Chicken Salad Can You Freeze?

If you’d like to make a batch of fully cooked chicken salad but do not want to risk the disintegration of the mayonnaise or Greek yogurt and the strange texture, there are different types of binding agents that you can make use of in their place.

My favorite ingredient to prepare chicken salad is pesto blend. It is extremely easy to freeze and gives a fresh and delicious taste to the pesto. You can also add some mayonnaise once it’s removed from the freezer to enjoy the perfect blend of the two.

Another option to employ to make chicken salad is to make Hummus instead of mayo and Greek yogurt.

It’s going to be more creamy as compared to pesto and will freeze and melt better than other emulsified options. Hummus-based chicken salads are less heavy than mayonnaise-based.

When you’re making chicken salad, there are a wide variety of delicious options that goes well with chicken salad.

If you are planning to store your leftovers in a freezer, then it is recommended to use a hummus or pesto foundation instead of mayo or Greek yogurt to avoid splits after thawing.

How to Freeze Your Chicken Salad Correctly

The best method to let your chicken salad that is to take your salad out from the fridge and allow it to chill in the refrigerator overnight, particularly in the event that you’ve used mayo for the base.

Because mayo is prone to spoil when kept at room temperature for a long, freezing it in the refrigerator can keep your mayonnaise from degrading and keep you from becoming sick.

If you’ve frozen a hummus, pesto, and Greek or yogurt-based chicken dish, it is possible to let it defrost at the counter over a couple of hours without a lot of worries. Be sure not to lose track of it!

Another option is to place the dish of salad chicken in bowls filled with cool water and let it sit in the bowl until it has soft. It is important to use hot water, as it could cause your salad to spoil.

If you’re in a hurry, then the best method to let your chicken salad is to keep it in the refrigerator overnight. However, these other options are also viable when you’re looking for a quick fast meal.

How to Store Your Chicken Salad Inside The Fridge

When you’ve leftover Chicken salad, which you know is safe to eat within five days, you should definitely put it in the refrigerator since it is usually fresh and ready to eat all day duration.

For cooking in bulk, a grab-and-go portion of salad for chicken. You can keep them in bags or containers that are small, so you can be sure that each portion will provide enough for a complete lunch or snack.

I would suggest purchasing some containers in the market for this reason so that you can reuse their containers.

If you don’t care as much about the speed at which you can take your chicken salad out and eat it, you can store the entire container and take what you require when you’re eating it. The mix can be used to make sandwiches, salads, and wraps.

I wouldn’t suggest keeping ready-made sandwich sandwiches of chicken in your refrigerator for longer than two days as the filling could cause the bread to go slowly and become soggy.

If you decide to store it in one big container or in a number of smaller ones, make sure you follow these steps:

  1. Mix the chicken salad in a bag or an airtight container.
  2. If it’s sealed in a resealable package and you want to remove any air left in the bag prior to closing the bag. Eliminating the air will help keep the bag fresher for longer. If the mix is stored inside a container, you can place a piece of plastic wrap over the mixture and cover the lid.
  3. The date and the contents are on a small piece of masking tape prior to placing it in the refrigerator.
  4. Put in the refrigerator and consume for 5 to 7 days.

How to Make the Best Chicken Salad

If you’re looking to prepare an excellent Chicken Salad mix, make this delicious and easy recipe. Keep in mind that this is only an idea, and you can modify the ingredients to fit your tastes and what you have in your kitchen.


  • 2 chicken breasts cooked or the meat of half of a rotisserie chicken
  • 1/2 cup chopped walnuts or chopped almonds
  • 1 cup mayonnaise, as well as Greek yogurt
  • 1 heaping tablespoon Dijon mustard
  • 1 Celery Stem finely chopped
  • 4 finely chopped green onions
  • 1 clove of garlic, minced
  • 2 tablespoons of dried cranberries, currants, or blueberries
  • 1 lemon with the juice and zest
  • Fresh parsley chopped to 1 cup
  • 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
  • A few puffs of black pepper


  1. Slice the chicken to the desired size, then place it in an enormous mixing bowl.
  2. Mix the remaining ingredients to mix.
  3. Then, let it sit in the fridge for about 1-2 hours to allow the flavors to blend. It’s not necessary, but it will make a distinction in the flavor.
  4. Eat sandwiches inside, over a mixture of mixed greens served in a quinoa bowl cereal bowl in the wrap.

Roundup of Freezing Chicken Salad

If you are planning to keep your chicken salad in the freezer, the best option is to do this before adding mayonnaise or Greek yogurt because these ingredients may separate when the salad is thawed, giving it an odd texture.

In the case of leftover chicken salad, mix in a bit of mayonnaise or Greek yogurt after it has thawed to correct the problem.

A few chicken salad bases can be frozen without worry about texture once it has been thawed. These include hummus and pesto.

You could also try mixing the pesto with mayonnaise or Greek yogurt once it’s thawed for a delicious chicken salad.

After being frozen, the chicken salad lasts for around 3 months. The best method for thawing it is to allow it to sit in the fridge for a few hours, particularly when you’ve used mayonnaise.

Are you using any other favorite ways to make your perfect salad of chicken? Please share them by leaving a comment!

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.

Exclusive Coupons & Discounts and Yummy Recipes!

Sign up to our free newsletter!