The Best Substitutes For Anchovies

What is the best alternative to anchovies?

The best substitute for anchovies is Worcestershire sauce since anchovies can be found in the ingredients list. Other options include shrimp paste, fish sauce paste, sardines sauce miso, and capers Kalamata olives, but it depends on the recipe.

Anchovies are a particular kind of topping. They’re not for everyone however there are plenty of people who truly appreciate these toppings. However that they’re often difficult to locate or purchase.

There could be instances when someone has requested anchovies, and you want to substitute anchovies with a similar flavor to determine if it’s better.

If you enjoy the taste of anchovies or would like something similar to it. There are alternatives that one can make use of in the event of needing to. Certain of these substitutes might be surprising since most of the time, it’s the use of paste or sauce, but there are many different alternatives.

In this article, we’ll share with you the most effective alternatives to anchovies. If you’re looking to eat the flavor of a healthy salad, want an alternative pizza topping, or just want something that will work with the gourmet sauce you’re creating. We’ve got you covered!

Stay with us to discover the best alternatives for anchovies.

Guide To Substitutes For Anchovies

There are a variety of various things you could make use of anchovies. They are a favorite among chefs, particularly for dips and dressings however they are also widely used as an ingredient for cooking.

Below Are Some Of The Most Common Applications For Anchovies:

  • Pizza topping
  • Dressing (Caesar)
  • Salad topping
  • Sandwiches
  • Anchovies paste
  • Rubs
  • Dips
  • Pasta Sauce
  • Lasagna
  • French tart

These are only the most common examples. The main thing to note is that they are adaptable if you’re eager to try them.

Now, let’s take a look at some other options and the ones that might be best suited.

1. Worcestershire Sauce

Very commonly used alternatives to the anchovies are Worcestershire sauce. The reason for this is that Worcestershire sauce has anchovies as one of the ingredients, so you get that distinct and spicy flavor without the need for anchovies in the first place.

There is a chance that you have used Worcestershire sauce to cook things but did not know the contents up until reading this information. A majority of people don’t put Worcestershire sauce on pizza but it’s an option if you like the taste.

Worcestershire sauce can be a wonderful alternative to stews, soups, casseroles marinades, sauces, and stews. You can add a bit of a splash to Cesar dressing or any other kind of dressing or sauce that you’d like to make.

This is a liquid, which makes it easy to incorporate into whatever you’re cooking to get an interesting flavor that could make your dish stand out.

Do not stop using Worcestershire sauce because you’ve found out it has anchovies! Use it in the usual meals, but you can find new dishes and sauces you could explore and add the extra flavor to.

If you’re looking for a solid suggestion for Worcestershire sauce, we suggest the Lea and Perrins company. It is a natural sauce that is among the pioneers of Worcestershire sauce too. The sauce they use is Kosher and flavorful and full of taste that you simply will not find anywhere else.

2. Sauce For Fish Sauce

Here’s another sauce to consider for your substitute for anchovies. It is a great addition to almost every dish you cook. It doesn’t matter if you want to mix it into pizza sauce or include it in stew or soup or if you want to add the distinctive flavor you want to your dish, fish sauce could help.

It is important to observe the fact that fish sauce can be quite strong therefore you should try to only use small amounts. In general, we suggest Worcestershire as a substitute for fish sauce in items such as Caesar dressing or the majority of sauces.

It is recommended to use small quantities generally around half a teaspoon, or even less. Fish sauce is very powerful in taste.

The great thing with fish sauce is it’s extremely potent in taste. If you are using fish sauce, ensure that you use it in a dish that isn’t excessively strong. You can use it in soups stock, stews, or braises. It is also possible to use it as an infusion as well.

If you’re looking for the best fish sauce, you can try this recipe made by Thai Kitchen. They offer a wide range of great Asian sauce options. The sauce made from fish is made using top-quality ingredients. There are anchovies in the sauce however remember that it’s strong in flavor. This sauce has only four ingredients, and there is no MSG.

3. Shrimp Paste

If you’re making an Asian dish, or maybe you want to spice up your pizza with a hint of anchovy it is possible to use a shrimp paste substitute for your anchovies or anchovy paste. It is recommended to use shrimp paste in the same amounts in which you would make use of anchovy paste.

Pastes similar to these are often utilized for Southeast Asian and Southern Chinese dishes. You can make your anchovy or shrimp paste by grinding the meat, then fermenting it in salt. You can, however, buy them. Shrimp paste is usually simpler to locate in comparison to anchovy paste.

Shrimp paste can give you that zing of lively flavor, but without the strong flavors of anchovy. It is also a good choice for those who want something less sour.

Anchovy and shrimp sauce both have a strong flavor, so it is important to consider that when you create your recipe, however, it is.

Here’s a very popular shrimp paste recipe from Thai Shrimp that you may try if you are in need.

4. Sardines

If you’re looking for a true alternative to anchovies made of fish Try Sardines. This can be a challenge since the tastes are different, and so are the different textures.

Sardine’s flavor is a lot lighter than the anchovy flavor. If you enjoy the idea of crackers and anchovies, but you want something more light and palatable, sardines are a good choice.

You can utilize sardine fish fillets instead of anchovy fillets when you cook the dish correctly. In this instance, you should ensure that you include a hint of a sauce such as Worcestershire sauce to bring the flavor of anchovies into the dish.

The great thing about sardines is that they offer the option of a mildly flavored substitute. They’re a great alternative for those who are more concerned with how the food looks and having the fillets readily available.

Remember that the flavors are distinct differences, so they may not taste identical. It is possible to help by using the Worcestershire sauce, or even fish sauce with sardines, for whatever it is you’re serving.

Sardines are usually easy to locate at the majority of grocery stores, and this is a good solution if you require them. Make sure to include the Worcestershire. If you’re in need of a suggestion we suggest this recipe from the household favorite Chicken of the Sea.

5. Soy Sauce

An alternative to anchovies to get the funky taste can be Soy Sauce. It is a sauce, so it’s ideal in dressings, sauces, soups, and similar products. It is possible to add soy sauce to pasta sauce, or maybe pizza sauce too.

There are no anchovies found in soy sauce. It is made up of soybeans, water, and wheat, as well as salt and alcohol, but the flavor is intense, and it is a great substitute for flavor if you need to add that funky accent that is distinctive.

The best aspect of soy sauce is that it’s relatively easy to find or make at home. Most people are carrying soy sauce around in the fridges or pantry, making it the perfect substitute in the event of a need for an easy and quick fix.

Because it’s a sauce, it can be easily incorporated into almost any dish you’re cooking. When you’re making a Caesar dressing, making a pizza, or making another recipe, it’s an adaptable substitute that can be used.

If you are looking for a great soy sauce we suggest Kikkoman Japanese created Soy Sauce. It’s strong and bold and has a distinctive flavor. That’s where the substitution properties are at play and make it a viable alternative.

6. Miso – Vegan Alternative

Miso is a fantastic choice for those who require an alternative to anchovies that is non-meaty. Miso is made from soybeans to make the perfect paste that is both rich and delicious. It is made to be healthy and provide that delicious umami taste that foods such as anchovies and pastes are known for.

Miso is available in a variety of types. It’s typically either a liquid or a paste and both can be utilized for many different items as well.

Also, Miso is nutritious and has many nutritional benefits. A majority of miso contains things like protein, folic acid minerals, B vitamins, Vitamin E, and Vitamin K.

Miso is made in various ways, but it’s usually primarily soybeans. You should check the ingredient list to find out if there are any added ingredients or preservatives that are in the mix. Because the flavor is a lot smoky, it can be a good anchovy substitute.

Miso is most effective as a replacement for recipes that require broth, such as soups. It can also serve as marinades or be added to vegetables and in casseroles. Many people include it in noodles to make the broth that is used in the dish.

Miso is a versatile ingredient. While it may not taste like anchovies, it does be rich and strong in flavor that people typically use anchovies to make, so it’s very well as a substitute.

It’s a great choice. Miso Soybean Paste made by PuroRaw is a fantastic choice and it’s 100% organic, with a delicious flavor and natural ingredients. It’s impossible to go wrong with this one.

7. Capers

You’ve probably had the pleasure of seeing or hearing about anchovies in pizza, and perhaps you’re interested but don’t know where to begin.

Or perhaps you’re looking for something different because you love this idea! Capers can be the perfect alternative to anchovies on the pizza you’re eating. You can use capers to make a topping, or you can add them to the pizza sauce. It is a good choice in both ways.

Capers are a very popular alternative since they’re not just a paste or sauce They are actually a pea-sized item that can are sold in vinegar and salt mixtures. They have a flavor that is very similar to Anchovy but with less of a fishy taste to it.

You can make your paste or make them available as is and they’ll be great as an alternative to anchovies.

Capers are derived from a bush and are small buds. The reason they are a great alternative is how you prepare them and how they’re then sold. Capers impart a lovely taste that is not being overpowered or too strong in the dish you prepare.

Our recommendation for capers originates from Mina Non-pareil, which means is unrivaled, so it speaks for itself regarding the quality.

8. Kalamata Olives

Our final recommendation as a substitute for anchovy would be Kalamata olives. These olives are another excellent vegan alternative. They are renowned for their ability to be nearly sweet and tart in the same bite.

Kalamata olives are a light little fruity flavor, but what stands out is the tanginess of the juice the olives are packed in.

Use the olives to add texture, and the juice to add some flavor. It’s an excellent choice that doesn’t contain meat. If you’re replacing anchovy paste, apply roughly the same amount of ingredients as the amount you would have made for the paste.

The great aspect about olives is that they are adaptable and if you’re looking for some sort of paste or something you can use in salads This is a perfect choice! They’re delicious and fresh and can be utilized in a variety of ways.

We love this product that comes from Roland Foods. They originate from Greece and are delicious and rich too.

Interesting Facts & Questions

We hope you find this guide on how to select an alternative to anchovy useful and informative. We have made every effort to give you a choice to suit any circumstance and to be able to accommodate a wide range of needs so you can find something that suits various tastes as well.

We encourage you to take an examination of our question and answer section to find out if there’s other information that may be helpful to you.

Are There Substitutes For Vegetables For Anchovies?

There are many vegetarian alternatives to anchovies. It is possible to use miso, Kalamata olives or miso, or maybe seaweed as an alternative.

Although we didn’t include seaweed in our list of choices It has a strong taste and texture that can effectively replace anchovies for many varieties of meals. You can use seaweed in dishes such as pizza or salad.

What Makes Anchovies So Salty In Flavor?

The saltiness is due to the curing process that is done with the fish. They cure in vinegar and salt that gives them that salty, unique flavor that makes a statement. This is the reason why other foods that are salty like soy sauce or fish sauce are good alternatives.

Are You Able To Make Anchovy Paste?

It is possible to make your own, and you can prepare it with anchovies, or create it using a different replacement like shrimp or capers also. The typical paste is made up of mustard, garlic, thyme black pepper, vinegar, and some oil. It is made in different ways too.

Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, the founder and editor of YummyTasteFood! She's a seasoned food writer and editor with over a decade of experience in the hospitality industry as a former pastry chef, sous chef, and barista. When not writing about food, she explores new recipes or travels the world for culinary inspiration.